There is an update on the human consequences of SFBC International's (mis)management of clinical trials. 20 people have contracted latent tuberculosis after being exposed to a patient with active TB during a trial of an immunosuppressant agent at SFBC International's SFBC Anapharm Canadian testing facility, according to CTV. Bloomberg News noted that 11 were employees of the company, while the remainder were patients in the study. CTV suggested that all would have to undergo nine months of therapy (presumably to suppress their latent TB and lower the likelihood it would become active in the future.) An investigation by Health Canada is ongoing. Bloomberg news could not get officials of SFBC International nor of Isotechnika, which made the trial drug, to comment.
CTV interviewed Professor Trudo Lemmens of the University of Toronto, who summed up the major issues.
The pharmaceutical industries want to have drugs on the market and they want to have them on the market quickly.Lemmens also noted that commercial ethics board may not do a good job policing such trials.
So they contract research organizations to do the human subject research for them. These companies are paid for the outcome, which is to have the trials done as quickly as possible, and so they have significant financial incentives to recruit human subjects and research them very quickly.
While many may be doing a good job, it's possible in the current regulatory system to shop for the most convenient, the fastest and the perhaps most lenient research ethics boards which imposes the least restrictions on your clinical trial.In response to this case he suggested,
The current Quebec situation underscores the need for the creation of a watchdog to oversee the industry, as well as stronger federal and provincial regulations to establish guidelines and requirements for research ethics boards, Lemmens said.It sounds like parallel solutions are needed in other countries.
Sadly, this case provides yet another reminder about how skeptical we must be about much of the clinical research now going on that is financed, and now often performed and supervised by loosely regulated corporations. And that is coming from a proud supporter of evidence-based medicine who has long advocated for clinical research, and who put my money where my mouth is by signing up as a trial subject. This sort of story really hurts.