I often believe surveys of physicians about EHR's do not present the results candidly, but rather are selective in what is reported - and what is omitted - and generally sugar-coated.
I then presented a candid physician survey on EHR's that was not very complimentary of the technology's value to real-world practicing physicians.
The following candid, informal nurse's survey about EHR's came to my attention the other day via Google. The thread is on Facebook in the "Friend a Nurse" group pages and can be read at https://www.facebook.com/friendanurse/posts/654085127954821.
Apparently the thread got underway after someone posted the question " the June 25, 2013 Bloomberg News article "Digital Health Records’ Risks Emerge as Deaths Blamed on Systems" (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-25/digital-health-records-risks-emerge-as-deaths-blamed-on-systems.html) that mentioned my mother's experience.
|The EHR question posed on the "Friend a Nurse" Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/friendanurse/posts/654085127954821. Click to enlarge, or click Facebook link, which is public as of this writing.|
I note that I had no knowledge of this, nor do I know the responders. I did add a link to my Drexel website on health IT difficulties at the end of the thread, however, after I discovered it.
Here are the comments from both female and male nurses who belong to this Facebook group. I redacted the names, however they can be seen at the Facebook page itself at the link above.
Big problems when you have unexpected "downtimes".
July 15 at 1:10pm · 4
It is an absolute train wreck, I havent seen one record of mine that is not riddled with mistakes. Especially the allergies, they show me taking meds Im allergic too and not taking meds Im actually on.. A true mess!!And now the records are all intertwined. I dont like it at all!!
July 15 at 1:10pm
It is a nightmare!
July 15 at 1:18pm
I retired just in time so I don,t have to deal with this fiasco
July 15 at 1:19pm via mobile
July 15 at 1:19pm
I don't like them; my doctors don't like them; how it will affect patient care is still a 'jury out' matter, but we can guess it will NOT help.
July 15 at 1:30pm
our Rural Community Healthcare system is just now switching over to this..along with our hospital switching over to a totally new computer system..the 2 systems do not talk to each other..In my personal experience I find that the "computer" world takes us away from Direct Patient Care.(to busy playing "ring around the Rosie" on the computer..
July 15 at 1:40pm
I like them, but it is frustrating having "downtime."
July 15 at 1:41pm
I hear patients stating things like "my doctors don't know who I am because they don't look at me they are glued to the computer". It saddens me patients feel less valued. I've worked in places where they've had paper charts and places computerized. Seems the computers are redundant and I personally prefer paper charts. Chart one assessment not one assessment 4 different places.
July 15 at 1:44pm via mobile
It looks to me like physicians are cutting and pasting old histories and physicals, complete with the errors. Doctors in a local ER charted complete physicals on me when they did not get closer that 5 feet away. The records are difficult to read, difficult to find information, and not number in chronological order.
July 15 at 1:47pm
I dislike it . Besides the down time find it very impersonal . I don't feel as if I am giving my full attention to my pt, nor do I feel my PCP is hearing what I ' m saying . They are to busy putting in info on the computer . As for the down time you then have to work late to put in the info gathered while the system is down.
July 15 at 1:47pm via mobile
Electronic charting takes the skilled nurse away from the patient and puts them in front of a computer. Its NOT best for the patient or staff - the people who build the programs have not been at the bedside for eons....so the programs are time consuming, redundant, and inefficient.
July 15 at 1:51pm
I like EMR very much. The system we use is Allscrips, it is not perfect, but the benefits outweigh the problems. For example, I find most issues are human errors, such as poor spelling, incorrect entry in the proper records, entering incorrect doses. I love the fact that I can actually read and do not spend time deciphering not only the doctors writings, but my coworkers. I like having all the records in one place. There are issues for sure, but some of the issues is from companies who chooses to,purchase low quality EMR packages with poor support. The systems also need to be more standardized and "speak" to each other better. And folks at the end of the day it is your license at risk, do the things you were trained to do in nursing school, the 5 Rs remember those?
July 15 at 1:53pm via mobile
we are starting on it, let you know
July 15 at 1:53pm
In general I dislike it. If it 'goes 'down', you end up being unable to obtain vital information. With the federal system we did have both the computer records and the paper records. This was fine with inpatient informaton. I dislike it when my computer crashes and I can't get anyone to come look at it or fix it. They had a message line which we never had a call back from. I'd have a whole dept be down and non one to repair it. It's very frustrating on a triage line. This made scheduling appts impossible. Lack of vital information could be lethal to critical care patients...Far less pro's than con's. It's just a bad decision all together..
July 15 at 2:01pm
if THE GOVERNMENT CAN GET INTO YOUR RECOREDS SO CAN ANYONE they can hack anywhere now a days and it is scary///
July 15 at 2:05pm
anyone over 25 most likely hates it
July 15 at 2:09pm
I quit 2011...did CPOE no issue but more more is coming seems like q mo. or so keeps adding dig. stuff...hosp. worked with kept changing sys...used to ask myself why fix when not broken also once you got use to it thats when they change...they shld hire more nurses aux. ppl...do not know what to do with their money. Stressout...no more nursing for me . New grads savvy but this boomer did it for 38 yr. Enough is enough!!
July 15 at 2:14pm via mobile
Takes time away from pt care too much:-)
July 15 at 2:34pm
I work in a hospital and I hate it! I feel like I spend more time looking at the computer than at the patient. We have to document the same thing in multiple areas...big waste of time! Also our ER and OR's use a different program and we are not able to access this information when a patient is admitted to the floor. We also use Physician OE and the system we have it is hard to get back to look at an already viewed order. I feel this is dangerous and orders are missed all the time. It is just a ticking time bomb before someone is going to get hurt!
July 15 at 2:35pm
The med was there then disappeared.....software is only as good as the person using it. A PERSON DELETED THE MED! Pharmacies, nurses, and MDs use the computer did it as an excuse. Never understood how I corrected MARs every month and they were worse the next month...the computer did not do it alone. I dislike the MD playing on the computer and half listening to me.
July 15 at 2:38pm
Recently I have had md's not put a patient back on home meds because he/she could put them in correctly. I had to call the doctor on call at night to get these medications in place. The pt was also missing vital medications they needed for their diagnosis. I feel like in some cases emr is not safe. There however some cases where emr is helpful.
July 15 at 2:43pm
it will get better with time...
July 15 at 2:45pm
I worked at a VA until I retired, and I loved it. It is so much easier. Lets face it, anyone that wants your information is going to get it anyway.
July 15 at 2:57pm
I have used EMR in hospitals, home health and hospice for the past 20 yrs. When used within the same corporation w many offices it is very efficient. In that state corrections dept it was very helpful w continuity of care. the medical record follows the inmate to what ever unit they may transfer to. HIPPA is even more important with the EMR systems.
July 15 at 3:14pm
We just changed our system to a new one. It took a large group of staff over 18 months to develop our documentation system. The nursing portion is great. The med ordering part is difficult to use. The docs are all complaining about the system. They want to continue writing their orders.
July 15 at 3:17pm via mobile
We have had epic for over 5 yrs it is a great system.just wish computers worked better always having to shut down and reboot. Has saved us a few times with preventing med errors.covenant healthcare did a great thing when they got this system
July 15 at 3:18pm via mobile
I think it is an injustice to the Patients We are more than a computer file
July 15 at 3:24pm
It helps with a history when a patient is unable to provide
July 15 at 3:29pm via mobile
Plus it may have contacts address patients previous baseline behavior I'm a psych nurse so we utilize this type of system
July 15 at 3:30pm via mobile
Takes time away from patients, goes down too often, difficult when hospitals change systems. There should be a universal system, so info can be shared.
July 15 at 3:40pm via mobile
EPIC is terrible when it comes to outpatient chemotherapy and research. It is cumbersome and takes so much time away from patients. EMR's are here to stay and I think it's a great thing, for the most part, but sheesh make it easy on the provider, will ya?
July 15 at 4:07pm
we fear medication errors because some doctors start up home meds that are no longer correct. getting used to it is the hardest. the younger nurses are much more efficient and comfortable with it.
July 15 at 4:16pm via mobile
I agree with Noelle, it took focus away from the patient because it was cumbersome and repetitious, and because of the environment we had to keep the people moving through recovery....so it was dreadful. I was happy to retire and leave it to others to deal with.
July 15 at 4:30pm
I've worked with electronic T-system, Promed blue, Meditech, etc and all have their advantages and disadvantages, but the major disadvantage is that we don't do patient care anymore...we do computer care...I could also go on and talk about the fact we also don't get to spend as much time with our patients because of patient ratios and patient loads and the computer charting we have to get back to...
July 15 at 4:32pm via mobile
you are right on target here.....I retired because of this, there is very little patient care, it is indeed computer care !
July 15 at 5:00pm · 1
Nursing Informatics Institute How has nursing been involved in the planning and implementation of these systems? Feel free to share your experiences, it is very interesting to hear about your practice.
July 15 at 5:15pm
I love the electronic records. I do not love all the different styles ect programs out there. So many glitches. Patient's need to be proactive and as involved in their healthcare and that of their loved ones as possible. That means bringing ALL of your med bottles with you to each and every doc visit you go to. I don't care how many times or how many diff docs you see in a week, ALWAYS take ALL of your meds in the ORIGINAL bottles. Where I work there is 100+ doc's in this group, each doc office has access to same record I see when the patient comes to us. Each doc office can ad or make changes to the chart accordingly, so if you don't bring your meds with you to each visit and doc A changed a med and made the notation in the chart we see it but can't verify it. ALWAYS keep an updated list of meds in your wallet/purse for those emergencies when you don't have your meds. Include on this list, your surgical history, your medical history(Diabetes, hypertension ect ect ect), who your PCP is and a #, allergies, blood type, your wishes as far as DNR ...... It will save your loved ones precious time and allow them to focus on you, and not that new pill doc so & so started you on for her diabetes, I think. Anyway, with so many spoons in our medical records here, I catch mistakes all the time where a med has been deleted/added ... By another office. Usually because the patient did not bring the meds, or the patient is a poor historian of their own medical history and the family has no clue. Be proactive people, don't trust us to do it all. Get the dam electronic records fixed so they make sense, and stops all this confusion ..... Why so many different types and formats are needed is beyond me.
July 15 at 6:01pm
not the systems that cause the problems, staffers that program only what they think is important when making diagnosis.
July 15 at 6:37pm
Love it - but when they go down.....
July 15 at 6:39pm
Mostly like it. Rather type than write. Does take more time than paper note, but overall I like it. I agree when I see patients & when I or my family is the patient, MD hardly looks at you; too busy inputting data.
July 15 at 6:52pm via mobile
July 15 at 6:52pm
it is a huge improvement! and a potential life saver - no more figuring out what that handwriting is saying.
July 15 at 7:13pm
I generally like EMRs but some programs are so damned redundant (charting the same IV start every time you admin an IV med?) and/or lacking in -- how do I put it? -- intuitiveness. Sometimes I really wonder if anyone actually working with patients was involved in the design or implementation of some of the programs we use.
July 15 at 7:31pm
Has it's good points and bad points. But I spend more time on the computer, then at the bedside.
July 15 at 7:55pm
I think computer charting has went way overboard and takes the nurse away from the bedside. How does family view nurses that are at the desk on the computer all the time?
July 15 at 8:27pm
it is disconcerting to the patient and or family if the health care provider starts firing questions and then spends the entire visit looking through the chart instead of listening to the patient's effort to provide a history of symptoms. No eye contact diminishes the interaction significantly!
July 15 at 9:15pm
for some things they are O.K. but everything no. Maybe scanned for some things. Now I have not thought out a plan for which, maybe someone with more time than I have could do a better job.
July 15 at 11:36pm
Haven't seen it work too well.
July 16 at 1:04am
It takes a lot of patience to get it implemented into a facility. The inservices that we
have had are few and basically it is a learn as you go. When everyone is finally sure of how to do it, it will be OK but is taking a long time for all of it to be taught to us
July 16 at 7:31am
mountains of paper, I mean mountains...
July 16 at 10:22am
as nurses, we are buried in paperwork... so are the docs... looking for a way out, we all THINK the digital answer with EMR is THE way... BUT nobody has proved it is superior, or really saves time or workload... and now the GOVERNMENT is pushing us into a costly and complex system
July 16 at 11:14am
I think the comments (largely negative with several "positive but with significant concerns") more accurately reflect EHR reality "in the trenches" than the marketing propaganda emanating from government, the health IT manufacturers, the academic pundits, and other "see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil" triple-simian hyper-enthusiasts.
|On EHRs: see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil|
Of course, the hyper-enthusiasts will call these opinions "anecdotal", but as one investigative reporter who does work in the EHR sector opined when sent the Facebook page:
"That's a lot of anecdotes."