Saturday, July 13, 2013

Kim Kardashian, Meet Electronic Medical Records

In yet another example of breach of medical record privacy (, Kim Kardashian's privacy on the birth of her daughter, as well as the privacy of more than a dozen other patients, was violated between June 18 and June 24:
Workers fired in privacy breach at L.A. hospital popular with stars

LOS ANGELES | Sat Jul 13, 2013

(Reuters) - Five medical workers have been fired over a patient data breach at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, the Los Angeles facility said in a statement, while celebrity website TMZ reported on Saturday that the hacking effort targeted reality star Kim Kardashian.
Cedars-Sinai, a favorite destination for celebrities seeking medical care, said in the statement it has a "high standard for security" and "in this case that standard was violated."  [How do ordinary hospital workers, medical assistants, and even a volunteer as below violate a "high standard for security", I wonder? - ed.]

Kardashian, the star of the reality television show "Keeping Up With the Kardashians," gave birth on June 15 at Cedars-Sinai to daughter North West, whose father is Grammy-winning rap star Kanye West.

Cedars-Sinai officials declined to say whose privacy had been breached, but the hospital said it "informed the affected patients" and apologized to them.

The breach of 14 patient records occurred between June 18 and June 24, the hospital statement said.

TMZ reported that Kardashian checked out of Cedars-Sinai about a week after she gave birth and was contacted by the hospital and told she was one of the patients whose records were accessed.

TMZ, which cited unnamed sources, said Kardashian's family suspected a leak of information at Cedars-Sinai after media reports disclosed details Kardashian had not revealed to anyone.

Representatives for Kardashian did not return calls or emails seeking comment on Saturday.

The Cedars-Sinai statement said four of the workers who inappropriately logged onto the hospital's information system to access patient records were employees of local physicians with staff privileges at the hospital.

The other workers were a medical assistant employed by the Cedars-Sinai Medical Care Foundation and a student research assistant who was a volunteer, the hospital said. As a result of the privacy breach, the five medical workers with ties to Cedars-Sinai were fired and the volunteer barred from working there, it said.

Cedars-Sinai said that while it had no indication "any criminal acts were committed by the individuals" it was reaching out to law enforcement agencies in "an abundance of caution."

It looks like the "high standard for security" needs some work.

(A paper chart could have been sequestered, of course, not permitting its access by riff raff, but then there would not be all the tremendous advantages of today's commercial EHRs such as detailed at

-- SS


Steve Lucas said...

It was reported Friday that the Russian government has put out to bid a request for typewriters. For young readers these are those funny things with a keyboard that then use a swing arm or ball that impacts paper, and are not in any way connected to the internet.

The stated reason for the request was for security purposes since a typewriter leaves no electronic footprint.

I remember trying to line up forms on a typewriter and still use a manual typewriter to type address labels. This may not be such a bad idea for those who want privacy in their personal records.

Everything old is new again.

Steve Lucas

Anonymous said...

Patients should be offered the paper record option to avoid being victims in this privacy breech epidemic.

Anonymous said...

This is the place that deinstalled a CPOE system several years ago.

It should have remained deinstalled. Doctors there suffer retaliation if they enable the adverse events to become highlighted.

The national HIT scandal must be halted.

Anonymous said...

Cedars-Sinai, a favorite destination for celebrities seeking medical care, said in the statement it has a "high standard for security" .

Pathetic if this represents what happens in medical centers with high standards or security.

This has become the standard.